Just recently, a high ranking Pakistani cleric, one Munib ur-Rehmen, asserted that “Islam does not allow anybody to take lives of innocent people by any means.” However, when he was grand mufti, two years earlier, he also said that “truly Islamic” states must kill the apostate from Islam. Considering his former statement, that Islam forbids the taking of “innocent” lives, has Munib been caught fibbing? Either way, this anecdote occasions the question: who is “innocent” in Islam?
Whereas other Muslims may shy away from this question, opting for the naïve Westerner to simply assume that “innocence” in Islam is akin to the liberal West’s notions of “innocence,” al-Qaeda—which seems to be supported by nearly half of the Muslim world—has been only to happy to clarify this matter.
Back in December, the terrorist organization’s primary media conduit, al-Sahab (the “clouds”) announced that al-Qaeda’s number two, Ayman Zawahiri, would be taking questions from the public and that he would “respond as soon as possible.”
Then, a few months later in April, according to the Associated Press, Zawahiri released a 90 minute audio tape, “billed as the first installment of answers to the more than 900 questions submitted on extremist Internet sites by al-Qaida supporters, critics and journalists.”
In response to a question that suggested al-Qaeda was responsible for the deaths of innocents in Baghdad, Morocco, and Algeria—Muslim areas where countless terrorist attacks in the name of al-Qaeda still occur daily—Zawahiri adamantly maintained that “We haven’t killed innocents,” not in any of those regions mentioned; “nor,” added Zawahari, “anywhere else”—which obviously includes 9/11, the London and Madrid bombings, and the rest.
Was Zawahiri being facetious, or does he truly deem all those killed in the aforementioned attacks as not “innocent”—that is, guilty?
5 comments:
Pastorius,
Excluding Muslims who are thoroughly secularized and reject Jihad and Sharia, to call one of them peaceful is a joke. "Kill all apostates, says peaceful Muslim cleric" by definition that is not peaceful. It could be translated as "Kill anyone who once thought the way we do, but now rejects our way of thinking." to even think along those lines, is to be filled with hatred, and no genuine man of peace could except it.
Zawahiri et al?
They are absolutely serious, and their consciences are untrammeled by any disquiet
This is how they come over as peaceful when intrviewed by Western media. They say, "Islam denounces the killing of innocent civilians." The truth is that even in the widest interpretation of Quran and Hadith, it is only Muslim civilians who are innocent. Kuffar civilians cannot be deemed innocent because they have rejected the word of Allah. They are therefore guilty and can be attacked.
Somehow, we need to 'wise up' our media to ask the correct questions, such as, "Do you regard non-Muslims as being innocent?"
Citizen Kane,
That should not be too much to ask. But, we are so inured in our Judeo-Christian "Love your neighbot" pagadigm that we can't imagine there are people in the world who would reject that paradigm as a matter of principle.
Post a Comment