Tuesday, February 06, 2007

American Islam's Hip New Face: Reza Aslan


Someone who just keeps catching my attention and turning up more and more in appearances lately is the Iranian-American author and analyst, Reza Aslan. Admittedly, he has been a bit hard to miss in recent months, and whoever is representing him is really starting to promote him in the media, which is a brilliant move, because this guys is golden. Doing the circuit of media appearances on the strength of the success of his recent book No god but God: The Origins, Evolution, and Future of Islam as well as becoming a commentator for such outlets as "Slate Magazine", NPR, as well as a Middle East Analyst for "CBS News", Aslan has been popping up in the most hip and fresh settings. His web site is stylish and well organized, with a new MySpace.com page promoted as "under construction". Through his site, one can read excerpts of his books (along with glowing reviews) as well as his other writings, and also find a perfectly organized list of his charismatic television appearances which can then be viewed.

Everything about Aslan seems to be on the 'up and up' as well as the 'up and coming', and it's easy to see why. Far from being a combative and stodgy representative of CAIR or any other taqiyya-factory type of group, Aslan's just the stylish everyman. He's not Middle America, far more cosmopolitan, but in a lovably modern and 'emo' sort of way. He's laid back and witty, with a humble sort of sense of humor that comes across as relaxed and diffusive in the face of any other TV guests who might be worked up about religion in any way. Holding a Masters degree in Theological Studies (from no less than Harvard) and on his way to a PhD, Aslan has ample knowledge at hand whenever a discussion starts going in a direction that may make Islam look negative. He also possesses and uses the same sort of wit that comedians associated with The Daily Show (on which he has been a well-received guest) use to make anyone making a sincere argument in favor of any conservative or Christian point of view look automatically foolish and outmoded.

I'm not offended by Reza Aslan, certainly not repulsed by him in the way that most of us are when we see a representative of CAIR show up to misinterpret issues until they're no longer recognizable. In fact, as far as Muslims whom I've known personally go, the Western-raised refugees of Iran's decades of turmoil are frequently the best assimilated, usually the least serious about their family religion. Persians, like Turks, are not Arabs no matter how closely their countries are to the heart of Arabia. The same cultural standards just do not apply, and with Persians the Islamic sect is not the same as that of most of their neighbors as well (being Shi'a). Anti-theocratic attitudes are often very strong, as are views favoring reform within Islam. In the US, many apostates are found amongst the Iranian born as well as many who simply favor acting more Western than adhering to the strict codes of Islam, certainly in comparison to the insanity of Wahhabism. No, Reza Aslan is the friendly and witty friend you'd want to encounter at parties, were it not for one thing.

No, not bias and the fact that he's Muslim. Despite the slick job of promoting that he and his representatives are doing, Mr. Aslan comes with a caveat. He is going to make the fool of anyone who fears Islamic encroachment in the West, let alone terrorism. He is going to demand respect for his Faith. Open dialogue though it may seem, be prepared for the most regularly cited examples of "Christian atrocities", or simply less than shining moments in Western history. I have yet to hear his take on Israel. But as far as mockery of more Fundamentalist sects of Christianity, as well as any reverence of Western Civilization, Aslan's part of the crowd that sets everything up so as to make themselves all come out as the hip kids and their opponents end up playing the frustrated fool.

In a step much lower that this, however, the other growing tactic that Aslan plays right into the cast of, is this business of turning those who continue to point out the giant elephant of Islamic terrorism and violence in the room as delusional alarmists. On television (that isn't "24") and in more and more mainstream discussions, the mere mention of Muslims or the Jihadi ideology being a threat to the West is being laughed off as though it is a figment of our imaginations. One of the elements making this possible (other than the possibility of the reality of Jedi Mind Tricks) is ironically the passage of time. The farther we get from 9/11/01 with no more successful attacks on the U.S., the more the moonbats act as though 9/11 were an aberation. The other growing method is to act as though anyone keeping our eyes on the Global Jihad is simply screaming that "they sky is falling".

Exemplary and rational seeming new faces such as Reza Aslan along with his essays and television appearances are ready-made to step into this scheme, helping to slowly change perceptions in our world. Helping to marginalize those willing to study and catalogue the growing unrest to outright violence with which Islam and Muslims are increasingly existing in our world. Keep your eyes open, people. Keep them open, and keep them looking for stylish new faces, like that of Reza Aslan.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Another Tariq Ramadan.

Anonymous said...

Britain has Tariq (aka Taqiyya) Ramadan - we've been blessed (/ note of sarcasm) with Reza Aslan.

Both snakes of the poisonous variety.

Epaminondas said...

Aslan states POINT blank in his book he is an apologist, and finishes his book by stating he thinks what is 'going on' is 'good' becuas eit means there will be an Islamic reformation.

Unfortunately, the reformation is over, and his 'side' lost, and are frankly apostates.

It's a great book, but in a stand up debate with the Qutbites or Khomeinists he gets wiped every single time.

Why?

Because in the end they 'takfir' guys like him, and everyone else shuts up in fear after people like him have their heads bouncing down the street, or enjoy the view from the end of a piano wire swinging from a lamp post.

Sorry but that's how it looks from here.

Good book, probably an ok guy, but dead wrong on the reformation, and unwilling to sound the trumpet to kill the killers.

Pastorius said...

Epa,

Tell me how this guy could be an ok guy if he conflates the sins of Christian extremists and those of Islamic extremists?

C'mon Epa. How could that possibly be?

It's like equating the sins of Lyndon Johnson with those of Adolph Hitler.

Kiddo said...

I just want people to be aware of this guy. He's just so.....likeable. He's one of the cool kids in the crowd, especially in these discussion format shows I've seen him on. The episode of Bill Maher's show was my introduction, and is a perfect example.

Sunday on C-Span's Book-TV there was a debate about modern religious strife, with the guests being Aslan, an Atheist author, and the third I think was Jewish. Yet the topic that kept coming up (the show did not have my complete attention) was modern Christianity in the U.S. It was completely absurd.

But this post is to make people aware of Mr. Aslan and his emergence onto the stage of the "world affair discussion shows", be they on Comedy Central, CBS News or NPR. Aslan is all of the modern guy presence that a group like CAIR could never, ever manage to muster. But his web site is also filled with information about him, links to his essays, excerpts from his books, and clips from his TV appearances. That is why I urge you all to go and check it out, do some more digging on your own along with some reading, and figure this guy out. I didn't have time for a more complete report, but I had enough time to write up a few impressions and the information to let everyone else able to access his works.

Please do take a look at this guy and keep a spare eye on his appearances. It's his ability to make people who are worried about violent Islam look foolish that worries me mainly.

Anonymous said...

just because he is stylish, modern, hip, and looks like he may have spent some time in SOHO or the Village doesn't make him someone we should keep our eyes open for...rather someone we should keep our eyes on...deception is part and parcel of what the Qur'an teaches...don't be fooled...Exemplary and rational seeming as you put it...seeming is the key word here...when he is out rallying Muslims to denounce terrorism, denounce bin Laden, reform Iran, reform Islam then and only then should we praise him...until then he's making a nice Western buck with a good PR man

Anonymous said...

I'll have some trust in him when he has earned a few fatwas of death.

Kiddo said...

Anon--that's what I meant, our eyes ON, he represents a new tactic at wearing people down who are still vigilant. I was meaning what you were saying.....long day;)

Pastorius said...

Anonymous said: I'll have some trust in him when he has earned a few fatwas of death.


I think that wins the prize for the most intelligent response to this post.