Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Nero, Rome, Potassium Iodide and All That

It's bad enough our ditherer in chief golfs while the world burns but at least and for once you would hope the Administration would keep the story straight, especially on something as frightening to so many as radiation poisoning.

But no. Two California officials state they don't think sstocking up on potassium iodide (KI) is a necessary nor necessarily good idea. And then U.S. Surgeon General Regina Benjamin turns around and says it's a worthy precaution.

What's a poor West Coaster to do? To think?

First of all the only thing the KI will do is protect the thyroid from radioiodine. That is probably the least dangerous thing that will come out of those reactors if they go into full meltdown. Some of the will also release cesium, uranium 232, plutonium and a whole bunch of other things that, should exposure in significant doses occur, will make you wish all you had to worry about was KI.

But meanwhile, taking the potassium iodide carries with it a host of potential nasty side affects. The kind that will put you off your feed just reading about them. Goiters. Acne. Nausea and vomitting. Fever. Mouth sores. Skin rash. Stomach pains. Irregular heartbeat. Numbness or tingling of the hands or feet. Metallic taste in the mouth.

Told ya.

So, if it were me I wouldn't be panicking and stockpiling it (one retailer sold 6,000 bottles over the weekend when he usually sells 60 in a week). And taking it now for no reason with all that to look forward to? I don't think so. I might feel different if I lived in Seattle or Portland or Los Angeles. And I certainly wouldn't advise someone who lives near a reactor, or anyone who might be in the path of this (if, indeed, it comes this far) from keeping some KI on hand.

But the Administration's response to all this, along with the SG's recommendation today, along with the government of Japan not having THEIR story straight (granted, they have their hands full enough I understand that so get someone, just one person, to act as media point on these releases) and the American press getting stupid about are our plants safe what if this happens at one of our plants what if this crosses the Pacific how high is the likelihood don't you think it's higher than that etc. causing otherwise (Semi)rational people to run around like ninnies because the sky might be falling (psst -- it's probably just a bird shitting on your shoulder). And at the same time Libya has gone to page 2, unrest in Egypt (still) and elsewhere is nearly a footnote or sidebar item. Israelis have stopped ships bound for Egypt with arms and for Gaza with Iranian arms.

Look, I'm no nuclear physicist. I never served on a nuclear sub. I'm not even Jimmy Carter.

But if you live in Topeka or St. Louis and really feel the need, then instead of buying 4 or 5 or a dozen bottles of KI (which goes for about $20 a pop depending on where you get it) why not just get 1 or maybe 2 bottle and use the rest of the money for something you may really need? Like ammo for when the Jihad comes. Or better still donate it to the relief efforts in Japan right now where they are dealing with sleeping in the open in sub freezing temperatures, have no food or water available?

And for heaven's sake, Mr President, the WORLD is melting down around you so put down the clubs and sit the fuck down at your desk for awhile.

Anyway, here's what set off this incoherent rant:

Surgeon General: Buying Iodide a "Precaution"
Conflicting messages appear in the effort to buy iodide tablets
By LORI PREUITT

The fear that a nuclear cloud could float from the shores of Japan to the shores of California has some people making a run on iodine tablets. Pharmacists across California report being flooded with requests.

State and county officials spent much of Tuesday trying to keep people calm by saying that getting the pills wasn't necessary, but then the United States surgeon general supported the idea as a worthy "precaution."

U.S. Surgeon General Regina Benjamin is in the Bay Area touring a peninsula hospital. NBC Bay Area reporter Damian Trujillo asked her about the run on tablets and Dr. Benjamin said although she wasn't aware of people stocking up, she did not think that would be an overreaction. She said it was right to be prepared.

On the other side of the issue is Kelly Huston of the California Emergency Management Agency. Huston said state officials, along with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the California Energy Commission, were monitoring the situation and said people don't need to buy the pills.

"Even if we had a radiation release from Diablo Canyon (in San Luis Obispo County), iodide would only be issued to people living within a 10-mile radius of the plant," Huston added.

Santa Clara County's public health officer Dr. Martin Fenstersheib told the Mercury News he also does not recommend getting the tablets, adding some people can be severely allergic to the iodine.

"There is no reason for doing it," Fenstersheib told the paper.

Either way, the pills are hard to get. eBay prices have skyrocketed.

7 comments:

Silverfiddle said...

I apologize for stating the obvious, but he is completely unfit for the job. It was a collective fit of euphoric stupidity that elected him, and now we see that elections do have consequences.

We may actually be better of with him being detached.

midnight rider said...

DON'T APOLOGIZE!

I agree. We look kinda bad when the Leader of the Free WOrld is making his March Madness predictions instead of attending to business but his attending to business is nothing to crow about, either.

Epaminondas said...

Th worst part is, once the panic KI buying starts, you feel you have to BUY if you live on the west coast.

My wife was diagnosed w/thyroid Ca in 1995. If you get it right away you are more likely to die of flu in your 90's...BUT, you will have surgery and or radiation every other year for more than a decade. You will have no thryoid and prob no parathyroid and need pills every day the rest of your life.

Once the buying starts, the urge to FIND IT SOMEWHERE becomes a background sensation ... there all the time.

But chances of exposure of any significance in Cali .... almost infinitesimal.

Did anyone anywhere on the west coast become ill after August 1945?

The radiation release then was many hundreds of quanta greater.

Always On Watch said...

MR's excellent turn of phrase: our ditherer in chief.

BHO is more worried about his basketball picks than leading our nation.

Pastorius said...

I haven't been worrying about it myself.

I went to buy Potassium Iodide. They didn't have it. I didn't go back, or go anywhere else. And, I hadn't thought about it since.

I agree with Epa.

And thanks, MR, for the information. This is an important post. I did not realize how bad it could be were someone to take Potassium Iodide if they were not exposed.

Sheesh.

Anonymous said...

I purchased the pills immediately post 9/11 given the potential threat to a nuclear facility within 75 miles of my residence. At the time of purchase, it was stated these pills do not have expiration concerns, and should not be taken unnecessarily due to all those possible health complications. As a worrywart parent, it bought peace of mind at the time.
Now, I just pray for the people of Japan who will be facing the massive tasks ahead.

***************
Another nagging thought . . .given the high tech capabilities of the Japanese, robotics, which can be operated remotely, appears to be a technology which is under-utilized in these circumstaces. I'm actually stunned nuclear entities continue to rely solely on human intervention for explosive and radioactive events of today.

Pastorius said...

Good point about Japanese Robotics. That is a big question mark, isn't it?

I will be buying the Potassium Iodide tablets as soon as this crisis blows over and they return to a normal pricing.