Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Does Dana Milbank Have A Point?

Check out this August 21, 2012 opinion piece in the Washington Post (copied and pasted in full because the WaPo has tightened up on access without a subscription):
Signs of divine intervention for Republicans?

Has God forsaken the Republican Party?

Well, sit in judgment of what’s happened in the past few days:
●A report comes out that a couple dozen House Republicans engaged in an alcohol-induced frolic, in one case nude, in the Sea of Galilee, where Jesus is believed to have walked on water, calmed the storm and, nearby, turned water into wine and performed the miracle of the loaves and fishes.

Rep. Todd Akin, Missouri’s Republican nominee for Senate, suggests there is such a thing as “legitimate rape” and purports that women’s bodies have mysterious ways to repel the seed of rapists. He spends the next 48 hours rejecting GOP leaders’ demands that he quit the race.

Weather forecasts show that a storm, likely to grow into Hurricane Isaac, may be chugging toward . . . Tampa, where Republicans will open their quadrennial nominating convention on Monday.

Coincidence? Or part of some Intelligent Design?

By their own logic, Republicans and their conservative allies should be concerned that Isaac is a form of divine retribution. Last year, Rep. Michele Bachmann, then a Republican presidential candidate, said that the East Coast earthquake and Hurricane Irene — another “I” storm, but not an Old Testament one — were attempts by God “to get the attention of the politicians.” In remarks later termed a “joke,” she said: “It’s time for an act of God and we’re getting it.”

The influential conservative broadcaster Glenn Beck said last year that the Japanese earthquake and tsunami were God’s “message being sent” to that country. A year earlier, Christian broadcaster and former GOP presidential candidate Pat Robertson tied the Haitian earthquake to that country’s “pact to the devil.”

Previously, Robertson had argued that Hurricane Katrina was God’s punishment for abortion, while the Rev. John Hagee said the storm was God’s way of punishing homosexuality. The late Jerry Falwell thought that God allowed the Sept. 11 attacks as retribution for feminists and the ACLU.

Even if you don’t believe God uses meteorological phenomena to express His will, it’s difficult for mere mortals to explain what is happening to the GOP just now.

By most earthly measures, President Obama has no business being reelected. No president since World War II has won reelection with the unemployment rate north of 7.4 percent. Of the presidents during that time who were returned to office, GDP growth averaged 4.7 percent during the first nine months of the election year — more than double the current rate.

But instead of being swept into office by the worst economic recovery since the Great Depression, Republicans are in danger of losing an election that is theirs to lose
. Mitt Romney, often tone-deaf, has allowed Obama to change the subject to Romney’s tax havens and tax returns. And congressional Republicans are providing all kinds of reasons for Americans to doubt their readiness to assume power.

The Politico report Sunday about drunken skinny-dipping in the Sea of Galilee gave House Republicans an unwanted image of debauchery — a faint echo of the Capitol page scandal that, breaking in September 2006, cemented Republicans’ fate in that November’s elections. The 30 Republican lawmakers on the “fact-finding” mission to Israel last summer earned a rebuke from Majority Leader Eric Cantor and attracted the attention of the FBI. The naked congressman, Rep. Kevin Yoder (R-Kan.), admitted in a statement: “[R]egrettably I jumped into the water without a swimsuit.”

A boozy frolic at a Christian holy site might have been a considerable embarrassment for the party, but it was eclipsed by a bigger one: Akin’s preposterous claim on a St. Louis TV program that pregnancy is rare after a “legitimate rape” because “the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.”

Republican leaders spent the next 48 hours trying to shut Akin’s whole thing down, but after a period of panic (a no-show on Piers Morgan’s show led the CNN host to show his empty chair and call him a “gutless little twerp”), Akin told radio host Mike Huckabee on Tuesday that he would fight the “big party people” and stay in the race.

The big party people had a further complication: In Tampa on Tuesday, those drafting the GOP platform agreed to retain a plank calling for a constitutional amendment banning abortion without specifying exceptions for cases of rape. In other words, the Akin position.

For a party that should be sailing toward victory, there were all the makings of a perfect storm. And, sure enough: Tuesday afternoon, the National Weather Service forecast that “Tropical Depression Nine” would strengthen into a hurricane, taking a northwesterly track over Cuba on Sunday morning — just as Republicans are arriving in Florida.

What happens next? God only knows.
In my view, the a lot of people of the Christian Right have set themselves them up for what Milbank is saying.  In fact, I've been waiting for the Christian Right's day of judgment because of the many outlandish statements made over a period of decades.

I'm not feeling very optimistic about the November 2012 outcome after some of the GOP's recent screw-ups.

Addendum: Check out the comments section at the WaPo web site. As of this moment, there are 4591 comments!

5 comments:

Nicoenarg said...

Wow, I didn't expect WaPo to write such a piece of crap article.

I mean I expect some fellow Christians to decide on behalf of God what natural occurence is God's wrath and what is only a natural occurence (you know, whatever suits their needs at times) but for WaPo to print something like this is irresponsible.

But then again, I shouldn't expect anything less from the media these days.

If Romney loses in Nov. that's going to be on the conservatives, especially because of articles like this and others going "yup, we've lost, we're hopeless!". I mean, if you think about it logically, you have got to be pretty darn idiotic to think that Obama is going to win this election, no doubt.

Have conservatives forgotten that Obama and Biden put together and their Democrat cronies have done and said things far more idiotic and stupid than the Republicans (Akin's remarks are of course pretty moronic but then the Republicans have distanced themselves from them)?

Anyway, its a moot point talking about these things in a logical manner.

Believers on both sides will either cry heaven or hell depending on how they feel on any given day. Our Christian brethren for centuries have been crying wolf about the world coming to an end, now they have started doing the same with American elections. If one wants to believe a hurricane is a sign from God...sure go ahead. But please tell me how this is different than thinking that being sick is a curse from God (never mind that germs are at play here) and that mentally sick people are demon possessed?

I say "get a grip" but everyone is free to believe what they want.

Always On Watch said...

As one considered a member of the Christian Right, I've been saying for a long time that all the harping on God's will in politics and in the weather is a dangerous road.

Many not on the Christian Right have been making fun of the Christian Right. Honestly -- and it pains me to say this -- these critics have a point.

The Christian Right is trapped in its own "logic."

I don't see the essay as irresponsible at all. Not that I LIKE the essay.

But the warning signs for the Christian Right have been ignored by the Christian Right. Chickens may come home to roost in November. **sigh**

Epaminondas said...

Gee, I didn't realize until this moment that Dana Millbank was a faith based rightist christian, who prolly think the world got here in 7 actual days 5750 years ago or something.

I am actually AMAZED,
A
M
A
Z
E
D
that these people are so in denial and fear that they can rational THIS kind of fearful HOPE against hope.

If this election doesn't go the way 1980 did, with food and gas prices SKYROCKETING in front of any american who goes to a grocery store ... WE WILL DESERVE THE GOVERNMENT WE GET.

Island for sale...anyone coming

FreeThinke said...

There's an old saying that has always resonated well with this 72-year-old conservative-libertarian:

American politics always boils down to a contest between The EVIL Party and the STUPID Party.

I'll give everyone three guesses as to which is which.

"Straining out gnats while swallowing camels" is what The Stupid Party tends to do. If you don't know who they are, you are probably a member in good standing.

"In general the art of government consists in taking as much money as possible from one class of citizens to give to the other."

~ Voltaire (1694-1778)

I agree with Voltaire. Politics is all about money and acquiring enough power to be able push people around and bend them to your will, and that's ALL it ever has been or will be in my never humble opinion.

Issues like Abortion, Right to Die and Gay Marriage should have NO PLACE WHATSOEVER in the political arena. They are PERSONAL and RELIGIOUS matters that function only as three large -- and very smelly -- red herrings that give the D'Rats a TREMENDOUS advantage, because harping on these things makes Republicans look foolish, naive, out of touch with reality, and potentially tyrannical.

Concentrating on Abortion and Homosexuality makes it LOOK as though Republicans are eager to establish a THEOCRACY. That frightens the hell out of people -- as well it should.

I'm a Christian, certainly a fiscal conservative, but probably a social liberal. There are far more people like me than there are of the crowd who wants to micromanage the inner-workings of every woman's vagina along with the direction and purpose of every man's penis.

The Conservative Movement is DOOMED if it continues to cater to the radical beliefs of Backwoods Bible Thumpers and Mediaeval Papists.

Many are scared to death of permitting SHARIA to be established within our borders. So am I! But everyone should be EQUALLY terrified at the thought of the reemergence of a Christo-Fascist State.

The United States of America my have been partially founded by strait-laced, iron-mouthed, agate-eyed Puritans, but it was also partially founded at the same time by worldly Soldiers of Fortune, deported criminals, and worldly, sensual, materialistic members of The Church of England.

Those groups were highly pragmatic because they had to be in order to survive, but they had little in common. And yet, they managed to forge an alliance that defied -- and finally defeated -- the then-most powerful nation in the world.

If ever a miracle has occurred, surely the American Revolution was it.

What we are doing to ourselves today is not only moronic, it is shameful and degrading.

And fools like this Akin character from The State of MISERY ought to be FORCIBLY EJECTED from the political arena. He wouldn't have survived ten minutes after displaying his idiocy if we had men like Ethan Allen and the Green Mountain Boys around today.

We've allowed ourselves become a bunch of PUSSY-WHIPPED COWARDS with NO COMMON SENSE.

Sign me,

DISGUSTED aka FreeThinke

FreeThinke said...

I'm astonished and amazed.
America is crazed.
My country now is dazed
And much too quickly fazed.
Zanzibar's stock has raised
Europe's ill appraised
Democracy's been razed.


~ FT