Sunday, April 12, 2009

Can We Talk?

Want to cover a little recently familiar ground here. This is certainly not meant to stir the pot or create discussion though certainly have at it if you like.

ODS. Obama Derangement Syndrome.

Oh no, here he goes again, says you.

Hear me out, says I. Have a drink first, if need be. I’ll wait. Hell I’ll even join you. But you’re buying.

A number of us at IBA have made our feelings about ODS quite clear. We urge caution on it. Be careful we don’t fall into the same trap that the BDS crew did for the last eight years. Don’t let it draw your focus from the real and known issues we’re up against.

But understand this: amongst ourselves we’re not even in agreement on what always constitutes ODS. Pasto & I may agree on one piece, but not on another. And we could be very wrong on all of it.

But the last thing I want to do, and I think, though by no means speak for him, Pasto would agree, is stifle quell or censor discussion in any way. Unless you’re a raving raging batshit lunatic who’s to say you’re wrong or we’re right. That’s what comments are for, to hash it out. Discuss. Just because it isn’t our opinion doesn’t mean it isn’t worth being heard.

I bring this up because earlier Christine had a very good post up. A commenter and I thought the conclusion of the piece trod upon ODS. That Obama is a closet Muslim. We respectfully disagreed. To me, for now at least, to draw that conclusion would mean that Michelle and his girls are as well, at least if he were the hardcore Muslim some might think. They’d be in hijabs etc. Or he’s a Manchurian Candidate Muslim, a mere pawn in a much larger dirtier game. I can’t reach that conclusion. Not yet.

To me he seems more a product of Chicago politics heavily influenced by some very questionable characters. And a product of the media itself, the more they fed on him, the more his own self-importance grew. And sympathetic to Muslims oh yes. Possibly because of his early education.

But I can’t agree he wants the willful destruction of the United States and Sharia imposed. Nor could I see Rev. Wright calling for Sharia in the U.S. That would be counter to what little I understand of Black Liberation Theology. Socialism, maybe – MAYBE – down with the White Man, hell yes. Sharia, no. Sharia and Socialism, Sharia and Communism, are not compatible.

But that is my opinion and your mileage may vary. And I have no more right to shut you up on your opinion – again, batshit loons need not apply – than you do to shut me up.

So it bothered me when Christine’s piece disappeared (you can still read it HERE ). She came, or more correctly Atlas came, to a different conclusion than I. The post suggests Obama is a closet Muslim. I say he is uncommonly sympathetic to them. To a dangerous degree.

The point is, though I’m not sure why she did, I wish Christine had not taken that post down. It had worthwhile points and was worthy of discussion. So one commenter and I didn’t agree with all of it. So what? I’d rather it was discussed than think someone feels they shouldn’t post something because they feel we may disagree. Pasto and I have put up some real boners in the recent past. It happens.

As long as you’re not calling for the assassination or other physical harm of our President – yes, he’s our President right or wrong for better or worse – or any of our elected leaders we can talk. I’ll disagree vehemently when you start throwing around words like Nazi and I don’t need to go into why again. Or if you start saying he’s the bastard son of a European Socialite and Gwarop Captain of the Royal Guard from the Third moon of Saturn. But otherwise we can talk. Behind every tall tale, behind every fish story, there’s likely to be at least AT LEAST a kernel of truth. Heck, even the birth certificate issue isn’t yet settled, a new challenge has been brought by an election official just a few days ago.

We’re about caution coupled with reasoned discourse and discussion. Ranting and raging at the other side.

We can argue it out. We're all growed ups here.

Ok, except for Pastorius. & myself. & Epaminondas. & Shiva. & Sir_publius (where the HELL has he been lately?) & Andre79. & Damien. & Abu Abdullah. & WC. & Always on Watch. & In Mary’s Image. & Christian Soldier. & Jewel. & Grant Jones. & Kevin. & Citizen Warrior. & Culturist John. & Ray Boyd. & Revere Rides Again. &. . .

10 comments:

Christine said...

Oh geez. Ok, I think you all got the impression I took the post down, due to the dissent. No, I took it down because I didn't want to taint the site with ODS.

And yes, a lot of the post was my words, not Pam's. (Everything in red)

I will put it back up.

Let the dissension begin....

midnight rider said...

Christine -- Don't worry about tainting this site. We taint nothing but a bunch of misfits drunks and hoodlums looking for a good time on a Saturday Night. If it smells like ODS we'll talk about it.

Glad you put it back up :)

Christine said...

And to show I'm not quite grown up myself, I did taint the late Mr. Rogers in my Sharia in the Hood piece. Not sure he would have approved. Oh well.

midnight rider said...

I, personally, would have been disappointed in you had you done otherwise :)

revereridesagain said...

At this juncture I will settle for the designation "Tool" as applied to Obama.

Ownership and provenance of said Tool not yet definitively established.

Said Tool may have been loaned out any number of times, thereby complicating question of ownership and provenance.

Current owner(s) may be trying to use Tool for a purpose to which Tool is inadequately suited.

Speaking of "misfits, drunks and hoodlums looking for good time on a Saturday night", hey, 3 out of 4 ain't bad...

midnight rider said...

I'm with ya, Revere, I'm with ya. Tool is perfect at this juncture.

Michael Travis said...

Obama sucks,,,read our articles.

However….I am an Israeli Jew.

George Bush & Family (Let’s include James Baker and Condi Clueless in that evil clan) have made it their life’s work to promote Islam…and destroy my people, country…and everyone I love and care for.

Two wrongs do not make a right.

And may I add...

B.Hussein O' isn't a clever agent of bin Laden or another Nordquist proxy.....he's Superfly. Obama's "Islam" is that of "The Moorish Science Temple", Elijah Mohammad, and other illiterate jailhouse messiahs. And forget about the Tele-Prompter theories too. Barry's stilted speech and measured delivery are merely a well practiced routine meant to avoid sounding like Louis Farrakhan or Mike Tyson. Barack Obama and his Acorn supporters haven't deceived the nation...... they've mugged us.

Rebellious Kafir said...

Christine, Didn't read the article yet, but I will. I just wanted to say...if you say ODS fast three times it begins to sound like "odious" ...I'm just sayin, thats all..

About ODS, I've questioned myself several times in the past months if I have begun to exhibit some of the signs and symptoms of a full blown case, but geez-louise, every damned road leads back to BO or his idiotic ideas about how to run the govt.

There is a VAST difference in just disagreement for the sake of disagreement vs disagreement based on sound logical reasons. So far, I'm still in the latter, at least as far as I can tell.

The_Editrix said...

"We respectfully disagreed [that Obama is a closet Muslim]. To me, for now at least, to draw that conclusion would mean that Michelle and his girls are as well, at least if he were the hardcore Muslim some might think. They’d be in hijabs etc."

Oh for heaven's sake! Why am I posting here if nobody ever bothers to read my entries? Or is my English too bad to be understood? My locic too flawed or convoluted? My style too boring? PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF IT IS SO!

Now I have to repeat large pieces of my own post in reply to a later one. Okay, here it goes:

Do you SERIOUSLY assume that a Muslim aspiring to be President of the United States would clad his wife and daughters in Muslim rags?
Obama is clearly well-versed in taqqiya. Is that a concept so alien to this Islam-critical forum?

Obama has been raised as a Muslim by his stepfather. There is no formal "conversion" to Islam. If you'd ever practised it, you ARE one. Apostasy is punishable by death. WHY do you think this prominent ex-Muslim is still alive? Don't you see beyond your own borders? For example what is happening in Turkey, the once stalwart of secular values? It has been re-conquered by Islam already. Islam was once stopped at the Gates of Vienna, at Tours and Poitiers, at Roncesvalles. Muslims have never forgotten that. Every spot where Muslims once trod, i.e. large parts of Europe, is Muslim ground forever. What about the re-Islamisation of the once pretty well assimilated Turks in Germany?

And if I say that every spot where Muslims once trod is Muslim ground forever that applies to Obama's mind and soul as well.

And you are seriously denying that Obama is a Muslim on the grounds that he isn't openly practizing Islam? As so often before, your Americanocentric views make me want to throw up. I wish you'd have to live, like we have, 2500, and not (taking America's geographical center) 7500 miles away from Mecca with Islam rubbed in our faces every day by an increasingly aggressive Muslim minority. We have to watch the frightening radical re-Islamization of the formerly relatively well-adjusted Turks in Germany, we have to suffer the rapid Islamisation of our cities, our institutions, our lifes. And all that by Muslims whose leaders are as well-spoken, apparently level-headed and non-radical as your Obama is. But who cares, Germany is far away, and has nothing to do with you.

And I take the liberty to quote myself again: Every spot where Muslims once trod is Muslim ground forever and that applies to Obama's mind and soul as well.

midnight rider said...

Editrix – "Why am I posting here?" you ask. Because you have an opinion you feel worthy of sharing, of having discussed.

That does not mean your opinion is the end all to the discussion.

I am aware that Obama was raised Muslim by his stepfather. I am aware you don’t formally “convert” to Islam. I am aware that you don’t leave. If you do you are an apostate punishable by death. Zawahiri, I think, even called for that for Obama during the primaries or General election.

So don’t talk to me like I’m some sort of errant idle schoolboy.

You have shown me nothing to prove in any way Obama is a Muslim bent on the intentional Islamic destruction of the Untied States. And I am no fan of Obama. It’ very easy to say he is practicing taqqiya to hide it when you cannot prove that he is hiding it. If he’s not acting the way we think he should as a Muslim he must be lying. Heck of an argument. Clearly well-versed in taqqiya? Where do you draw that fact from?

And you’re correct. I don’t live 2,500 miles from Mecca. But you are no more qualified to preach to me about what is going on in my Country than I am to preach to you about what is going on in Germany. I do, however, live within 150 miles each of Ground Zero and The Pentagon. And like so many others I nearly lost loved ones at both locations on 9/11.

So save the self-righteous indignation. It wasn’t American policies that put the wolf inside your door. Talk to your own leaders about that.

If you don’t like my Americanocentric view, tough. It ain’t chaning. Bring an airsick bag.