Sunday, September 11, 2011

The Crueler it is, the sooner it is over....should we have nuked instead of a 10 years and unlimited effort...

It's 10 years on and no REAL OBJECTIVE end in sight.

William Sherman said that war is cruelty, that there can be no way to refine it, and that the crueler it is the sooner it is over, and as a corollary, the fewer are the casualties.

Suppose we had simply erased, Kandahar, Jalalabad, Kabul, Tora Bora etc, hours after Mullah Omar refused to turn Bin Laden over. Suppose 30-50 targets had been wacked by 100 kilotons each.

Certainly American casualties would have been nearly or completely non existent.

We may had avoided invading Iraq, for the lessons to the world would have been salutary.
Many would have condemned us, but in the end would less people be dead, and a more final reckoning in our favor be realized?

8 comments:

Undaunted said...

Sounds like a plan.

Christine said...

Yes, yes and yes!

Nice or not, it ended WWII. A lot of world military, American and Japanese citizens lived a long life afterwards.

The type of "nice" war we are waging, has and never will work.

Anonymous said...

In a bi-polar world where it is ONLY the West vs Islam, I'd have to agree. Blammo. However, your observation that - "many would have condemned us" might quickly have morphed into "many will band together to attack us" thus resulting in catastrophic escalation and a potential WW3.

As it stands WW3 looks to be shaping up as a more focused and rational IWW.

You're probably right, Obama, America has not, and may never be at war ..., at least in the sense you're saying it (i.e) as an isolated element. But dar al Harb will surely begin to get its collective act together one day soon. And America will be a large part of that.

Pastorius said...

The really sad thing is, we may go another 10 years like this, with more death, destruction and damage to our economy, and THEN, we will come to this conclusion.

Reliapundit said...

YUP. BEEN BLOGGIN THIS VERY THING FOR 6 YEARS.

IN THE NEXT PHASE OF THIS WAR, WE WON'T BE THE FIRST TO USE A NUKE.

SIGH.

christian soldier said...

you've stated exactly what I have been saying- I get and have
eye rolls' - how about you!
Carol-CS

SamenoKami said...

We don't have gonads anymore.
I would add Mecca and Medina to the list, just to be on the safe side and cover all bases.

Anonymous said...

They want to live in the 7th century be my guest. I'd love to see the rest of the world combine to send them there. Lower their rabbit-like birth rate, too, as well as get rid of a lot of fleas, ticks, & a slew of four-legged vermin to keep the two-legged vermin company.

Silverlady