Sunday, November 30, 2008

A New Movie: "The Messenger of Peace"

Given the title, what kind of movie do you think it's going to be? Here's an excerpt from an article on Fox News:
If film producer Oscar Zoghbi has his way, Americans will be soon be flocking to movie theaters to see a film about the Prophet Muhammad and his followers that Zoghbi hopes will clear up misconceptions about Muslims, including what he says is "the understanding that all Muslims are terrorists."

Nonie Darwish, the author of the upcoming book "Cruel and Usual Punishment: The Terrifying Global Implications of Sharia Law," said the film will likely try too hard not to offend.

"The movie will probably avoid or justify Muhammad's violent and unprovoked battling years in Medina, where assassination and mass murder were done by Muhammad … in order to spread the religion, take control and silence his critics," Darwish said.

"We will probably see the image of Muhammad that most Muslims were spoon-fed in their religious education."

Robert Spencer, director of, said Western audiences looking to learn more about a religion tangled in stereotypes of suicide bombers will be disappointed by "The Messenger of Peace."

"They're already taking a stand on a controversial issue with the title alone, denying and downplaying the manifest fact that numerous Muslims around the world have justified acts of violence by invoking Muhammad's words and example," Spencer said.

But Zoghbi says his film will very deliberately take a moderate approach.

"We are trying to depict the values and teachings of the Prophet. It's not a historical film in any way," he said.

"And it's not a Muslim propaganda film. This film is also for Muslims, and I hope it will encourage them to condemn violence."

One thing Zoghbi hopes to avoid is the violence and outrage in the Muslim world that has followed some recent depictions of the prophet Muhammad.

Islamic conventions forbid the showing of Muhammad in any form, and violence has often followed the release of newspaper cartoons, books and films that criticized or simply depicted the Muslim prophet.

In 2005, the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten ran a cartoon depicting Muhammad wearing a turban with a bomb in it, sparking riots that killed more than 30 people throughout the Islamic world. This year, protests began on news of "Fitna," a film critical of Islam, and Random House cancelled distribution of the widely anticipated book "Jewel of Medina" out of fear of such a reaction.

Zoghbi said that he will make every effort to ensure that "The Messenger of Peace" is in line with Islamic traditions.

"Islam itself doesn't stop you from showing the Prophet," Zoghbi said. "But it is convention and tradition, and we will abide by that. We do not want to offend anyone."

The film will also follow tradition by not portraying various close companions of Muhammad in human form. And the Dubai-based Dar Al Sharia Legal and Financial Consultancy, a branch of the Dubai Islamic Bank, has been hired to make sure the film is in keeping with Islamic standards.

"The Messenger of Peace" has a $130 million budget and is being funded by individual investors located throughout the Middle East — especially in Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Egypt. Zoghbi said that a list of investors is expected to be released next month, unless those involved object.

Zoghbi says he hopes his new film will bring people together.

"Nothing has been done on this for 30 years, and I decided it was time to build some bridges."

Bring people together. Build some bridges. What does that even mean? "Hey, you kafirs, let's all just sit down and figure out how you can be happy with us taking over the world. Now, what is it you don't like about paying the jizya?"


Anonymous said...

"...clear up misconceptions about Muslims, including what he says is "the understanding that all Muslims are terrorists.""

Not all of the students at Terrorist University have gone on to become professors ...

Torch to your Straw Man argument, Zoghbi.

Citizen Warrior said...

That particular line you quoted irked me as well, Anonymous.

Damien said...

Citizen Warrior,

If the people who are making this movie are not lying they are clearly ignorant. People should not write books or make movies about subjects they know nothing about.

Pastorius said...

This movie will likely do three things,

1) it will create a dialogue which will result in a lot of Westerners learning more about Islam

2) it will create a myth about Islam which will cause many ignorant Westerners to become more attracted to Islam

3) it will very likely cause some Jihadists to riot and kill, causing more Westerners to learn more about Islam.

I predict it will yield a net negative. That is, it will cause more people to accept the myth (that Mohammed was a Messenger of Peace) than the fact.

midnight rider said...

Most already accept the myth. This is just another nail in the coffin. See how he feels while he's trying to cross those bridges and some jihadi nails his ass by blowing it up when he's in the middle of it.

Citizen Warrior said...

I was thinking the same thing: The movie will probably not convert anyone to the belief Islam is benign because they already assume so.

In that case, the movie should do nothing but help us in our cause.

Anonymous said...

Your all pathetic, stay frightened because islam is spreading so fast, ha, there is nothing you can do. It's like a tsunami, u cant stop it but can only predict it.
You will all be judged one day, whether u believe it or not.

Muslim said...

No matter what any of you do with your blog and websites, you can never put down the religion of the one true God who created you and took care of you while you were in your mother's womb.
Islam will and is prevailing alhamdulilah!

Anonymous said...

those who talk about wars should not forget hwo all america became christian, I dont even talk about crusaders...

Anonymous said...

there is one god,his name is ALLAH and muhammed is a messenger from ALLAH

Tawhidtube said...

After killing so many innocent ppl now its time to build bridges? its tilting more towards a bribe! Just type "islam" on youtube and you will be amazed on how many material there is on the subject. Allah the lord of the heavens and the earth is sufficent for the spreading of his religion, although the film will be watched for entertainment basis rather then relying on Hollywood to rescue this religion which is destined to reach the four corners of the globe by Allah the most merciful. However I must admit I want to see it.

Amid said...

Here is the story of the rise and the existence of Muslim movement.